1989
【Best Novel】
Winner Something Wicked / (Carolyn G. Hart)
【Best First Mystery Novel】
Winner A Great Deliverance / (Elizabeth George)
【Best Short Story】
Winner More Final Than Divorce / (Robert Barnard)
1990
【Best Novel】
Winner Naked Once More / (Elizabeth Peters)
【Best First Mystery Novel】
Winner Grim and Punishment / (Jill Churchill)
【Best Short Story】
Winner A Wee Doch and Doris / (Sharyn McCrumb)
1991
【Best Novel】
Winner Bum Steer / (Nancy Pickard)
【Best First Mystery Novel】
Winner The Body in the Belfry / (Katherine Hall Page)
【Best Short Story】
Winner Too Much to Bare / (Joan Hess)
1992
【Best Novel】
Winner I. O. U. / (Nancy Pickard)
【Best First Mystery Novel】
Winner Zero at the Bone / (Mary Willis Walker)
【Best Short Story】
Winner Deborah's Judgment / (Margaret Maron)
1993
【Best Novel】
Winner Bootlegger's Daughter / (Margaret Maron)
【Best First Mystery Novel】
Winner Blanohe on the Lam / (Barbara Neely)
【Best Short Story】
Winner Nice Gorilla / (Aaron Elkins) & (Charlotte Elkins)
1994
【Best Novel】
Winner Dead Man's Island / (Carolyn G. Hart)
【Best First Mystery Novel】
Winner Track of the Cat / (Nevada Barr)
【Best Short Story】
Winner Kim's Game /(M. D. Lake)
【Best Nonfiction】
Winner The Doctor, the Murder, the Mystery / (Barbara D'Amato)
1995
【Best Novel】
Winner She Walks These Hills / (Sharyn McCrumb)
【Best First Mystery Novel】
Winner Do Unto Others / (Jeff Abbott)
【Best Short Story】
Winner The Family Jewels / (Dorothy Cannell)
【Best Nonfiction】
Winner By a Woman's Hand /(Jean Swanson) & (Dean James)
by caspi